diff --git a/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/EvaluationsReview.tsx b/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/EvaluationsReview.tsx
index 628cbfedcf..bc176f53a2 100644
--- a/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/EvaluationsReview.tsx
+++ b/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/EvaluationsReview.tsx
@@ -420,6 +420,7 @@ export function EvaluationsReview({
       {evaluationInput && (
         <EvaluationStepSettingsModal
           close={closeSettings}
+          isAdmin={isAdmin}
           evaluationInput={evaluationInput}
           templateId={templateId}
           saveEvaluation={saveEvaluation}
diff --git a/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/components/EvaluationStepSettingsModal.tsx b/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/components/EvaluationStepSettingsModal.tsx
index 816ccc05fd..e8255403c5 100644
--- a/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/components/EvaluationStepSettingsModal.tsx
+++ b/components/proposals/ProposalPage/components/ProposalEvaluations/components/Review/components/EvaluationStepSettingsModal.tsx
@@ -14,13 +14,15 @@ export function EvaluationStepSettingsModal({
   evaluationInput,
   templateId,
   saveEvaluation,
-  updateEvaluation
+  updateEvaluation,
+  isAdmin
 }: {
   close: VoidFunction;
   evaluationInput: ProposalEvaluationValues;
   templateId?: string | null;
   saveEvaluation: (evaluation: ProposalEvaluationValues) => void;
   updateEvaluation: (evaluation: Partial<ProposalEvaluationValues>) => void;
+  isAdmin: boolean;
 }) {
   const { data: proposalTemplate } = useGetProposalTemplate(templateId);
   const evaluationInputError = evaluationInput && getEvaluationFormError(evaluationInput as ProposalEvaluationInput);
@@ -42,7 +44,7 @@ export function EvaluationStepSettingsModal({
           Cancel
         </Button>
         <Button
-          disabled={evaluationInputError}
+          disabled={!isAdmin && evaluationInputError}
           disabledTooltip={evaluationInputError}
           onClick={() => saveEvaluation(evaluationInput)}
         >