Restoring a deleted file in a deleted subfolder causes unexpected behaviour

[maxemann96]

Actual behaviour:
Restoring a deleted file laying in an also deleted folder restores the file into the root of the groupfolder.

Expected behaviour:
The nested directory structure and the file should be restored (with the original permissions of the substructure).

To reproduce:

1. Create a group folder /groupfolder
2. Create a folder /groupfolder/sub with one file /groupfolder/sub/file
3. Delete the file /groupfolder/sub/file
4. Delete the folder /groupfolder/sub
5. Restore the file /groupfolder/sub/file

[pierreozoux]

I just reproduce, and I agree that it is unexpected.

[mejo-]

@maxemann96 and @pierreozoux can you still reproduce this bug with latest version of Groupfolder app on Nextcloud 23? I fail to reproduce the issue on Nextcloud 24 RC1 at least. Also, do you use special storage backends?

[pierreozoux]

We are using minio as a storage backend, but no longer using group folder 🙃

[mejo-]

Thanks @pierreozoux, so let's close this issue as non-reproducible for now.

[maxemann96]

Hey all, sorry for the very long answer time. This issue still persists. To retest it I created the following structure:

• Create a group folder /groupfolder
• Create a sub group folder /groupfolder/subGroupfolder
• Create a normal folder /groupfolder/subGroupfolder/sub with one file /groupfolder/subGroupfolder/sub/file
• Delete the file /groupfolder/subGroupfolder/sub/file
• Delete the folder /groupfolder/subGroupfolder/sub
• Restore the file /groupfolder/sub/file

Notice that the file is restored to /groupfolder/file. Which I find is very unexpected that the file gets restored into the root groupfolder. Tested on NC 24.0.1 with group folders version 12.0.0.

[jngrb]

As the bug can still be easily reproduced in our setup, I opened a new issue #2041