Skip to content

paper: preserve GRACE boundary and preregister next evidence - #4

Draft
ShuhaoZhangTony wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/grace-paper-assets-20260829
Draft

paper: preserve GRACE boundary and preregister next evidence#4
ShuhaoZhangTony wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
codex/grace-paper-assets-20260829

Conversation

@ShuhaoZhangTony

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Scope

Advisor-authored preservation and next-evidence draft only. The accepted manuscript is absent and is not reconstructed. Hongru Gao retains implementation, environment, experiment, and result ownership.

Exact identity

  • PR head: c8b06e08bf8beb04a3080814a9eae82e34cde153
  • artifact commit: 81a939ece431b9353858f06651d3cd41fb4e0eb7
  • base: 9f81318ecb12cbb5531034a574f6136f65d6b8e2
  • PDF: 2 pages

Boundary

The draft preregisters a structural-drift reconstruction decision across PPCSR, Terrace, and VCSR. It requires exact upstream pins, matched fixed-period/fixed-density/oracle arms, snapshot correctness receipts, winner-switch plus oracle-headroom, and explicit stop rules. Existing logs remain historical/unbound; no new result is claimed.

Verification

  • Tectonic exit 0, no warnings; both pages visually checked.
  • git diff --check: pass.
  • PPCSR build attempt: not run because cmake is absent; no dependency installed and no green build claimed.

Keep Draft; do not merge without explicit user confirmation.

@ShuhaoZhangTony

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@ShuhaoZhangTony 112 independent review requested for exact head c8b06e08bf8beb04a3080814a9eae82e34cde153. Advisor narrative only; no accepted-paper claim reconstruction, mechanism work, or experiment. Tectonic exit 0 (2 pages), 2/2 pages visually checked, diff check passed; host build remains unrun because cmake is absent.

@ShuhaoZhangTony ShuhaoZhangTony left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

51-paper final audit — PASS at exact head c8b06e08bf8beb04a3080814a9eae82e34cde153

Canonical repository/base, exact-head paper assets, independent Tectonic rebuild, bibliography/citations, and page rendering pass. The manuscript closes the project-specific seven-question contract with strongest baselines, matched arms, correctness oracle, metrics/gates, evidence boundary, and stop conditions; claims do not exceed the retained real-online/replay/simulation/probe/derived evidence, and NPU architecture claims are bounded to the documented causal chain where applicable. This PR remains Draft; this review does not merge it or authorize experiments.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant