Emit plain file when key is empty

[thomaslepoix]

Renewal of #338

Fixes: #120

[Mic92]

Currently I don't have a better name but defaultSopsKey sounds very confusing because it's quite overloaded as we have private / public keys everywhere. One has to reach out fo the description to figure out what it's for.

[Mic92]

For your usecase, do you actually need this option?
Is it not enough to set this instead?

{
  sops.defaultSopsFormat = "binary";
}

[Mic92]

Also here, can you not just set the format to "binary" on a per secret base?

[Mic92]

Suggested change

	format = "yaml";
	format = "binary";

[Mic92]

Suggested change

key = "";

[thomaslepoix]

For sops, treating the secret as binary is not the same as treating it as json/yaml with an empty key (whole file), binary puts everything under a data key:

cat file
{
	"acl": {
		"tokens": {
			"initial_management": "911578ef-e979-4811-b607-32b1e9819b85"
		}
	}
}

sops --input-type binary -e file
{
	"data": "ENC[AES256_GCM,data:hMbIl33ak/I4SP+eJtbHwGnUn40OfagGC7AHrKk12KcLbn4M/dRjOQ+h4OwOtfp/ZSo6lyRcZKllA/DI0V6z/pL072Hs/nTkJtDnSZorCOk4THOJ84QOYVe1mcEoptX03NGN,iv:MateN0FjgcpfTcZQ7xdCIBXJW7LjchGLiy3EIo9Kt7g=,tag:7IY0D/VIclNu6oudxtl/Hw==,type:str]",
	"sops": { ... }
}

sops --input-type json -e file
{
	"acl": {
		"tokens": {
			"initial_management": "ENC[AES256_GCM,data:VChCbEmx1Mri5siKZGeIL2f2DQR7aX9YVaXtlFGnwFfkugsc,iv:0nt21nZUKaGCdviDOSCyLDvjjfajZ6UK+Mat/8LZ80I=,tag:gsZ/kavDx/YLfxGjrl5ilQ==,type:str]"
		}
	},
	"sops": { ... }
}

And decrypting as binary a file that was encrypted as json/yaml won't work:

sops --input-type json --output file_enc_json -e file

sops -d --output-type json file_enc_json
{
	"acl": {
		"tokens": {
			"initial_management": "911578ef-e979-4811-b607-32b1e9819b85"
		}
	}
}

sops -d --output-type binary file_enc_json
Error dumping file: error emitting binary store: no binary data found in tree

This is likely not an encrypted binary file? If not, use --output-type to select the correct output type.

So as detailed in the issue, using binary format implies the file was encrypted as such which has several drawbacks:

• It breaks sops format detection, as json/yaml assumptions from the file extension becomes wrong, since sops-nix will decrypt as binary in the end. So the user has to remember this and act appropriately when encrypting secrets. Note this can go even worse when it comes to IDE plugins that brings sops support.
• It also breaks a selling feature of sops: diffable encrypted files, as everything is under the same key.
• It feels odd regarding sops that does not have such a restriction and thus generally unintuitive while learning sops-nix

---

Now, when the preferred workflow is "every secret its own file" instead of "all secrets in the same file, one secret per key", everything being json/yaml : defaultSopsKey just allows to be more concise than repeating key = ""; but I agree it is really confusion-prone regarding age/pgp keys and I would like to clarify that too. To be fair this confusion is already part of sops which takes the json/yaml semantic for "key" while also dealing with cryptographic keys.

Here is an example for my current use case:

  sops = {
    age.keyFile = "/var/lib/sops-nix/key.txt";
    defaultSopsKey = "";
    defaultSopsFormat = "json";
    secrets = {
      "certs/consul-agent-ca.pem" = {
        sopsFile = self + /secrets/dev/consul-agent-ca.pem;
        format = "binary";
        owner = "consul";
      };
      "consul-encrypt.json" = {
        sopsFile = self + "/secrets/dev/consul-encrypt.json";
        owner = "consul";
        restartUnits = [ "consul-rotate-gossip-encryption-key.service" ];
      };
      "consul-acl-initial-management.json" = {
        sopsFile = self + "/secrets/dev/consul-acl-initial-management.json";
        owner = "consul";
      };
    };
  };

[Mic92]

I see. Thanks for clarification.

[BKSalman]

hello :), I'm interested in this feature, will it be merged?

[thomaslepoix]

up